ERTC Refund Lawsuits: Is Now the Time to File?

Employers awaiting ERTC refunds face significant delays and uncertainty due to the IRS's processing halt. With many having waited over six months, they're now eligible to file refund lawsuits to expedite payment of owed refunds. Filing a lawsuit can bypass lengthy processing delays and may lead to quicker recovery. Employers must document their eligibility and refund amounts to support their claims. By taking proactive measures, they can avoid extended waiting periods and potentially recover attorneys' fees. As the IRS's moratorium on new claims continues, understanding the litigation process and options available can help employers make informed decisions.

Table of Contents

Key Takeaways

Employers who have waited over six months for an ERTC refund or disallowance notice may be eligible to file a lawsuit.
Filing a lawsuit can expedite payment of owed refunds, bypassing lengthy IRS processing delays.
The Court of Federal Claims may offer procedural advantages for faster resolutions, with no requirement for local counsel.
Proper documentation of eligibility and refund amounts is critical before filing a lawsuit to support claims and expedite the refund process.
With the IRS moratorium on new claims since September 2023, filing a lawsuit may be a viable option for employers to recover owed refunds.

ERTC Refund Claim Processing Halted

The IRS's sudden halt on processing ERTC refund claims in mid-July 2023 has left many employers in limbo. As a result, valid claims face significant delays. The moratorium, announced on September 14, 2023, was implemented due to an increase in invalid ERTC claims. Employers with legitimate claims are now forced to wait indefinitely for refunds. The IRS's move has caused frustration among businesses that were relying on these refunds. With no clear end in sight for the moratorium, many are considering alternative options to recover their owed refunds. The halt in processing has affected numerous employers, leaving them uncertain about the status of their claims. Delays in refunds can have significant financial implications for businesses, making it essential for them to explore other avenues.

Eligibility for Refund Lawsuits

Facing significant delays in receiving their ERTC refunds, many employers are exploring alternative options, including filing refund lawsuits. To be eligible to file a refund suit, employers must not have received a refund or disallowance notice within six months of filing their claim. Given the current processing timelines, most employers with pending claims have waited over six months, making them eligible to file a lawsuit. The eligibility criteria focus on timely filing and the lack of an IRS response. Employers who meet these criteria can consider filing a refund suit to expedite the payment of their owed refunds. By taking proactive action, employers may be able to recover their refunds more quickly than if they continued to wait for the IRS to process their claims.

Choosing the Right Litigation Venue

Employers who decide to file a refund lawsuit must next determine the most suitable litigation venue for their case. They have two primary options: U.S. district court or the Court of Federal Claims. The choice of venue can greatly impact the outcome and efficiency of the lawsuit.

Consider the following factors when choosing a litigation venue:

Procedural advantages: The Court of Federal Claims may offer streamlined procedures, leading to faster resolutions.
Representation requirements: Local counsel is not required when filing in the Court of Federal Claims, which can reduce costs and complexity.
Government representation: The U.S. Department of Justice Tax Division represents the government in both venues, ensuring a high level of expertise and consistency.

Documenting Refund Eligibility and Amount

As employers prepare to file a refund lawsuit, documenting refund eligibility and amount becomes a vital step in building a strong case. Employers should analyze the law and document their eligibility before filing a lawsuit. Claims should include evidence of eligibility and refund amounts to enhance the chances of settlement or stipulation. Clear documentation is essential in supporting the employer's claim and can expedite the refund process. Proactive lawsuits should be backed by thorough legal analysis to avoid extensive discovery and costly litigation. By documenting refund eligibility and amount, employers can strengthen their case and increase the likelihood of a successful outcome. A well-documented claim can also facilitate settlement negotiations with the IRS.

Litigation Strategy and Procedures

The strength of an employer's case relies not only on thorough documentation but also on a well-planned litigation strategy. Employers must consider the venue for their refund suit, as this decision greatly impacts the proceedings. The U.S. Department of Justice Tax Division represents the government in these cases.

Three key considerations when developing a litigation strategy include:

Forum selection: Refund suits can be filed in U.S. district court or the Court of Federal Claims. The Court of Federal Claims may offer procedural advantages and doesn't require local counsel.
Procedural approach: Streamlined litigation procedures can lead to faster resolutions.
Settlement negotiations: Employers should be prepared to engage in settlement discussions, potentially using qualified offer procedures to recover attorneys' fees.

Avoiding Extensive Discovery Processes

While developing a strong case is essential for employers seeking ERTC refunds, avoiding extensive discovery processes can be just as important in expediting the refund process. Protracted discovery can elongate the litigation timeline and hinder an employer's financial recovery. Employers filing ERTC refund suits can streamline the process by properly documenting their eligibility and substantiating their refund claims early on. Clear and compelling documentation can facilitate settlement agreements or stipulations, possibly limiting the need for expensive discovery. By proactively gathering and presenting evidence in a clear and concise manner, employers can strengthen their positions and potentially expedite their refund payments. Consequently, diligent preparation and an evidence-driven approach can pave the way for a prompter resolution.

Recovering Attorneys Fees and Costs

Fees and costs incurred during ERTC refund litigation can add up quickly, putting a strain on employers who are already awaiting reimbursement. Fortunately, there are opportunities for employers to recover some of these expenses. The IRS allows for the recovery of attorneys' fees in certain situations, but this is uncommon.

To recover fees, the following conditions must be met:

The IRS position must not be substantially justified: This means the IRS's stance must be deemed unreasonable or without basis in fact or law.
A qualified offer procedure must be followed: Employers must submit a settlement offer to the IRS, which is reviewed by a trial attorney and additional DOJ Tax Division attorneys.
The party must prevail in the lawsuit: If the IRS rejects the offer and the employer wins the lawsuit, some fees may be recoverable.

Expedited Refund Payments Through Lawsuits

In light of the IRS's moratorium on new ERTC claims and significant delays in processing existing ones, employers with valid claims are increasingly turning to lawsuits as a means to expedite refund payments. With the IRS halting claim processing in July 2023 and announcing a moratorium on new claims in September 2023, employers are seeking alternative solutions to obtain owed refunds. By filing a lawsuit, employers can potentially bypass lengthy processing delays and receive expedited refund payments. Eligible employers who have waited over six months without receiving a refund or disallowance notice can file a lawsuit in U.S. district court or the Court of Federal Claims. This strategic approach may help employers recover refunds more quickly and avoid extended waiting periods.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can Multiple Refund Claims Be Combined Into a Single Lawsuit?

She can combine multiple refund claims into a single lawsuit, but each claim must meet eligibility criteria, including the six-month waiting period, to increase chances of expedited payments and avoid extensive discovery.

How Does Filing a Lawsuit Affect Ongoing Business Operations?

Filing a lawsuit can greatly impact ongoing business operations, as it demands considerable time, resources, and attention from key personnel, potentially diverting focus away from core business activities and affecting overall productivity and performance.

Are There Any Alternative Dispute Resolution Methods Available?

She considers alternative dispute resolution methods, such as mediation or arbitration, which may expedite ERTC refund claims, but these options are typically unavailable until a lawsuit is filed and the court orders it.

Can New Evidence Be Submitted During the Lawsuit Process?

She can submit new evidence during the lawsuit process, but it's essential that it's relevant and wasn't previously available. The court will review and decide whether to accept the new evidence, which may impact the case's outcome.

What Are the Potential Tax Implications of Receiving an ERTC Refund?

Receiving an ERTC refund can have significant tax implications, including potential income tax liabilities, as the IRS considers refunds taxable income, and employers must report them on their tax returns, potentially impacting future tax obligations.